Skip to content

Free college sports predictions, leaderboards and rewards

Most Loyal Fans in College Sports: Which Athletes the Data Favors

The most loyal fans in college sports can't be measured directly. Here is what engagement data shows about which athletes and teams stand out.

Most Loyal Fans in College Sports: college football fans filling Sanford Stadium

Last updated: November 3, 2026


The most loyal fans in college sports can’t be measured directly, because nobody publishes how long fans stick around or how often they return. Engagement data is the closest public signal, so this update replaces our old opinion list with real numbers and explains what they can and can’t tell you.

Quick summary

  • No public ranking measures fan loyalty, so any “most loyal” list is partly a judgment call.
  • Engagement rate is the best public stand-in: how many followers actually react to a post.
  • In a fall 2025 ranking reported by Marketing Brew, Nebraska volleyball players posted some of the highest engagement among well-followed athletes.
  • Very small accounts can show huge rates, so followers and engagement need to be read together.

What Most Loyal Fans Actually Means

Three ideas often get mixed together:

  • Popularity is how many people follow an athlete.
  • Engagement is how many of them react to a post.
  • Loyalty is whether they keep showing up across seasons, including after losses.

Only the first two can be checked from public data. If you want the raw follower view, our list of the most popular NCAA athletes online covers it. Loyalty is what’s left to infer, which is why we treat engagement as a clue instead of a final answer. For the wider picture, see the power of fan engagement in college sports.

Athletes With the Strongest Engagement Numbers

The best recent public snapshot comes from a fall sports marketability ranking covered by Marketing Brew in September 2025. These are fall 2025 figures, so current numbers and rosters may differ.

Athlete School and sport Instagram followers Instagram engagement
Jeremiah Smith Ohio State football About 600K 28%
Arch Manning Texas football 480K+ About 16%
Harper Murray Nebraska volleyball 235K+ About 13%
Laney Choboy Nebraska volleyball 100K+ Above 26%
Ava Nucci Mississippi State soccer About 600K About 7%
Ryan Williams Alabama football 750K+ About 4%

The contrast between two wide receivers makes the point. Ryan Williams had the larger Instagram following, but Jeremiah Smith’s reported engagement rate was about seven times higher. If loyalty shows up anywhere in public data, it looks more like Smith’s line than a big follower count alone.

Why Nebraska Volleyball Stands Out

All of the top eight volleyball athletes in that ranking played for Nebraska. Andi Jackson, Laney Choboy and Maisie Boesiger each had 100K+ Instagram followers with engagement of at least 21%. Taylor Landfair topped 37%, and Ryan Hunter came close to 40%.

That lines up with what fans see from the Nebraska volleyball program, one of the strongest followings in the sport. It’s a useful reminder that team culture can matter as much as any single star, and it’s the closest thing in this data to the most loyal fans in college sports as a group.

The Small-Account Catch

High rates don’t automatically mean a big loyal base. The same report listed Maryland field hockey’s Fleur Knopert at about 44% with roughly 1,300 followers, and Northwestern’s Maddie Zimmer at about 33% with roughly 6,700. Those are strong communities, but small ones, and rates usually fall as accounts grow.

Older research points the same way. A 2021 analysis of All-Americans in 14 sports found that Olympic and non-revenue sports often had higher engagement rates than football, basketball and baseball, with football ranking 10th of the 14 in average engagement.

Why Engagement Affects NIL Value

Brands pay for attention, so these numbers have real value. On3 says followers set a starting point in its NIL valuation, and athletes who consistently show high engagement receive a boost. Those with low rates face a small reduction.

That helps explain why smaller-sport athletes with active audiences can compete for local and national deals. It also gives a practical test for readers: compare an athlete’s reactions to their follower count, then check whether the pattern holds after a tough loss. RallyFuel’s top college athletes list and the NIL Score leaderboard are good places to start comparing.

What Builds the Most Loyal Fans

  • Time: athletes who stay with one program for several years give fans longer to connect.
  • Consistency: regular posts through both wins and losses keep people around.
  • Team identity: programs with deep local followings pass some of that attention on to their players.
  • Authenticity: fans tend to respond to athletes who sound like themselves, not an ad.

These are reasonable patterns, not measured rules, and we don’t assign any athlete a loyalty score here.

FAQ

Which college athletes have the most loyal fans?

There’s no definitive answer, because loyalty isn’t publicly measured. Going by fall 2025 engagement data, Nebraska volleyball players and Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith stood out among well-followed athletes.

How is loyalty different from engagement?

Engagement measures reactions to posts. Loyalty means fans keep returning over several seasons, which public data doesn’t track directly.

Do high engagement rates mean more NIL money?

They can help. On3 says consistent high engagement raises an athlete’s valuation, but performance and existing deals matter too.

🗳️ Vote: Make your prediction for this week’s college football games on RallyFuel

Follow College Athletes on RallyFuel

Browse athlete profiles, make free game predictions and see the schools on the RallyFuel NIL Score leaderboard.

Rolly, the RallyFuel mascot

Written by

RallyFuel Team

The RallyFuel Team covers college sports for fans: game previews, rankings, rivalries, schedules and the NIL rules that shape the college game. We build our coverage from school, conference and NCAA sources where available, and we update posts when the news changes or a reader flags an error. RallyFuel is a free college sports fan platform for following athletes, making game predictions and earning rewards. It is not affiliated with any school, conference or collective.