Skip to content

Free college sports predictions, leaderboards and rewards

The Small Program NIL Playbook: Small College NIL for DII, DIII and Mid-Majors

Small college NIL rewards volume over size. This small program NIL playbook covers five plays for DII, DIII and mid-major schools, from local partners to selling density.

The Small Program NIL Playbook: Geneva College Reeves Stadium stands

Last updated: November 3, 2026


Small college NIL rewards volume over size, and the first year of revenue sharing hasn’t changed that. This update adds the new revenue-sharing numbers and tightens the five plays that work at DII, DIII and mid-major programs.

Quick summary

  • Small college NIL runs on many small, local deals rather than one big signing.
  • Revenue sharing is a Division I opt-in, so DII and DIII athletes earn from outside deals only.
  • Every sport on a small roster can earn, because no revenue pool has to go to one team first.
  • The best first step is a shared list of local businesses open to working with athletes.

Where Small College NIL Stands in 2026

The biggest headlines belong to the top of Division I. In the first revenue-sharing year, 319 of 365 Division I schools opted in, and 307 paid out $1.77 billion to 34,915 athletes. The cap was $20.5M for 2025-26 and is $21.58M for 2026-27. None of that reaches Division II or Division III, where athletes earn only from outside deals. Our D1 vs D2 NIL breakdown covers that income gap in detail.

Small deals are the norm. An AP report from 2022 put the median deal on one major NIL platform at just $53, and that figure is dated, but the shape holds: the price of entry is low enough for almost any local business. A 2024 report from the University of Indianapolis student paper described DII deals as often coming from small community organizations, with free meals in exchange for social posts as a common example.

Jack Betts shows what volume can look like. As an Amherst wide receiver, he had more than 35 NIL deals worth around $7,500 in cash and free merchandise by September 2022, some of them with local businesses. That averages a little over $200 per deal. None of them was big news, but together they added up for a Division III player.

Play 1: Build a Book of Local Partners

The most durable small college NIL asset is a standing list of local businesses open to working with athletes, kept where anyone on the roster can see it. As a simple illustration, twelve regional partners at $2,500 each would create $30,000 a year in activity across a program, and it would not depend on one star staying on campus. Athletes choose what fits them. The program keeps the list current.

Good places to start:

  • Credit unions and community banks. They want younger members and have a natural financial-education angle.
  • Grocery, convenience and restaurants. Lower dollar, high volume and easy to spread across a roster.
  • Health and wellness. Dental and vision practices, pharmacies and gyms all market locally.
  • Agricultural, industrial and trade employers. In many college towns they are among the largest employers, and few programs ever call them.

Start with in-kind deals and let them grow. Forty in-kind partners and eight cash partners give a roster far more entry points than two cash partners would.

Play 2: Sell Local Density

An athlete with 8,000 local followers can be worth more to a regional advertiser than a national name with 200,000 scattered followers. Almost nobody measures this, so do the work. Pull the location data on an athlete’s audience, compare it to the business’s trade area, and bring a number to the meeting. “Most of this audience lives within thirty miles of your three locations” is a pitch a marketing manager can take to her boss. The same local logic shows up at the top of the sport, as our look at jersey patch NIL deals explains.

Play 3: Treat Every Sport as a Front Door

At the top of Division I, money concentrates in football and men’s basketball. At DII and DIII there is no revenue pool to divide, so a softball player, swimmer or volleyball player can pitch a local business on the same terms as anyone else. Browse Division III programs or Division II programs and you’ll see how many teams each campus has to offer a local partner.

Play 4: Win on Speed and Specificity

Local business owners rarely have a marketing department. Make saying yes easy: one page, one clear deliverable, one price and one contact. Offer a specific activation, such as two posts and a store appearance during homecoming week, instead of a general partnership. Then send a short recap with what ran and how it performed. That recap is what turns a one-time deal into a renewal.

Play 5: Make Your Athletes Findable

A business can’t work with an athlete it can’t find. Keep bios, hometowns, majors and social handles current on school rosters and on public profiles like RallyFuel’s athlete directory and school pages such as Amherst. Rules vary by state and school, so athletes should also check disclosure requirements with their compliance office before signing. The NIL glossary helps with the contract terms.

The First 90 Days of a Small College NIL Program

  • Days 1–30: List 25 local businesses, confirm the compliance process and publish the list for the roster.
  • Days 31–60: Pull audience data for ten athletes across different sports and make the first ten calls.
  • Days 61–90: Close the first in-kind deals, send recaps and ask each partner for one referral.

For more on how collectives and local deals fit together, read Small-Program NIL in 2026, and see our guide to Division 3 colleges by state for conference context.

FAQ

Can Division III athletes make NIL money?

Yes. Division III athletes can sign outside NIL deals, as Jack Betts did at Amherst. Division III schools have no revenue sharing, so that income comes from outside businesses.

How much is a typical small college NIL deal?

Many are small. Betts averaged a little over $200 per deal, and plenty of small college NIL activity is free product or meals rather than cash.

Do DII schools get revenue sharing?

No. Revenue sharing is a Division I opt-in. The cap is $21.58M for 2026-27, and DII and JUCO schools have none.

Follow College Athletes on RallyFuel

Keep up with small programs and big ones alike. Find players in the athlete directory, compare programs on the RallyFuel NIL Score leaderboard, and make free game predictions.

🗳️ Vote: Make your prediction for this week’s college games on RallyFuel

Rolly, the RallyFuel mascot

Written by

RallyFuel Team

The RallyFuel Team covers college sports for fans: game previews, rankings, rivalries, schedules and the NIL rules that shape the college game. We build our coverage from school, conference and NCAA sources where available, and we update posts when the news changes or a reader flags an error. RallyFuel is a free college sports fan platform for following athletes, making game predictions and earning rewards. It is not affiliated with any school, conference or collective.